Skip to main content area Skip to main content area Skip to institutional navigation Skip to search Skip to section navigation

The Lawyer as Neutral

Founded in 1986, Penn Law’s Mediation Clinic was one of the first real case programs of its kind in the nation. With its cutting-edge technology-based instruction and breadth of sophisticated faculty-supervised fieldwork, it has maintained its preeminent place as a national model for mediation courses.

Mediation Defined

Mediation involves the intervention of a neutral third party into an existing or threatened dispute, with the aim of facilitating a negotiated resolution of the conflict. Lawyers are increasingly immersed in this arena, both as mediators and as traditional representatives of clients whose matters are subject to a mediation resolution. The number of disputes that are resolved through mediation now exceeds exponentially those that are tried in courts. It is also a subject of great interest to transactional lawyers.

Clinical Skills

The Mediation Clinic focuses on developing students’ skills and addresses the role and ethical issues in the mediation function. But, in the process, it teaches much more. By the end of the course students will have learned a great deal about listening and empathizing, dispassionately evaluating cases for litigation and advising clients in that realm, identifying solutions to problems and negotiating effectively, presiding over a meeting – in short, the skills that all lawyers need and that clients value.

Penn Clinic cases are featured in a THE PRACTICE OF MEDIATION: A VIDEO-INTEGRATED TEXT (Aspen Law & Business, 2d Ed. 2012), co-authored by Penn Law Mediation Clinic Director Douglas Frenkel, the multimedia book with which students are trained and which has become the text of choice for mediation clinics and courses around the nation. 

The Course

The course consists of two main components:

Classroom: students receive intensive skills training and engage in observations of outside neutrals in actual adjudications and mediations. Using discussion, video and simulation exercises, students learn the entire range of mediation skills prior to commencing fieldwork in the second half of the course. The classroom component continues with in-class discussion of student fieldwork experience, focused discussion of ethical issues and advanced skills topics and seminars on themes ranging from restorative justice to representation of clients in mediation.

Fieldwork: students are the frontline mediators in a wide array of cases. With a faculty supervisor present, students co-mediate an average of 4-5 cases per semester at courthouses, government agencies and at the Law School in areas that include civil litigation, criminal, domestic, campus student discipline and international child custody disputes and employment discrimination matters. Following every mediation, students debrief with the faculty supervisor to complete the learning experience.