Skip to main content area Skip to main content area Skip to institutional navigation Skip to search Skip to section navigation
Keedy Cup

This Year’s Case

James Erin McKinney was convicted of first-degree murder in Arizona and sentenced to death. At sentencing, the court refused to take into account his history of PTSD and childhood abuse. Mr. McKinney then brought a federal habeas petition, arguing that the state courts should have considered this evidence and that he should receive a new sentencing hearing. In this year’s Keedy Cup, Penn Law’s finest argue two questions: (1) whether the Arizona Supreme Court was required to apply current law when weighing mitigating and aggravating evidence to determine whether a death sentence is warranted, and (2) whether the correction of error under Eddings v. Oklahoma, under which courts must consider all relevant individualized mitigating evidence in capital sentencing, requires resentencing.