UNIFORM COMPUTER INFORMATION
TRANSACTIONS ACT
(Last Revisions or Amendments Completed Year 2000)
Drafted by the
NATIONAL CONFERENCE OF COMMISSIONERS
ON UNIFORM STATE LAWS
and by it
APPROVED AND RECOMMENDED FOR ENACTMENT
IN ALL THE STATES
at its
ANNUAL CONFERENCE
MEETING IN ITS ONE-HUNDRED-AND-NINTH YEAR
IN ST. AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA
JULY 28-AUGUST 4, 2000
WITH PREFATORY NOTE AND COMMENTS
Copyright © 2000
By
NATIONAL CONFERENCE OF COMMISSIONERS
ON UNIFORM STATE LAWS
September 29, 2000
The Committee that acted for the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws in preparing the Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act in 2000 is as follows:
CARLYLE C. RING, JR., 1401 H. Street, N.W., Suite 500, Washington, DC 20005, Chair
JOHN A. CHANIN, 715 S. Washington Street, Apartment B13, Alexandria, VA 22314
STEPHEN Y. CHOW, One Beacon Street, 30th Floor, Boston, MA 02108
PATRICIA BRUMFIELD FRY, University of Missouri School of Law, Missouri Avenue & Conley
Avenue, Columbia, MO 65211
THOMAS T. GRIMSHAW, Suite 3800, 1700 Lincoln Street, Denver, CO 80203
LEON M. McCORKLE, JR., P.O. Box 387, Dublin, OH 43017-0387
THOMAS J. McCRACKEN, JR., Room 600, 134 N. LaSalle Street, Chicago, IL 60602
JAMES C. McKAY, JR., Office of Corporation Counsel, 6th Floor South, 441 4th Street, N.W.,
Washington, DC 20001
BRUCE MUNSON, Revisor of Statutes Bureau, Suite 800, 131 W. Wilson Street, Madison, WI 53703
RAYMOND T. NIMMER, University of Houston, Law Center, 4800 Calhoun, Houston, TX 77204,
Reporter
GENE N. LEBRUN, P.O. Box 8250, 9th Floor, 909 St. Joseph Street, Rapid City, SD 57709,
President, 1999
JOHN L. McCLAUGHERTY, P.O. Box 553, Charleston, WV 25322, President, 2000
BARRY H. EVENCHICK, 8th Floor, One Gateway Center, Newark, NJ 07102, Division Chair, 1999
JOHN P. BURTON, P.O. Box 1357, Suite 101, 123 E. Marcy Street, Santa Fe, NM, Division Chair, 2000
DONALD A. COHN, 14 Gale Lane, Greenville, DE 19807, Co-Advisor
DANIEL S. COOLIDGE, 25 Franklin Street, Boston, MA 02110-2804, Law Practice Management Section
Advisor
MARY JO HOWARD DIVELY, One Oxford Centre, 40th Floor, Pittsburgh, PA 15219, Business Law
Section Advisor
GEORGE L. GRAFF, 30th Floor, 399 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10022, Co-Advisor
LYNN P. HENDRIX, 1700 Lincoln Street, Suite 4100, Denver, CO 80203, Intellectual Property Law
Section Advisor
FRED H. MILLER, University of Oklahoma, College of Law, 300 Timberdell Road, Norman, OK 73019,
Executive Director
WILLIAM J. PIERCE, 1505 Roxbury Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48104, Executive Director Emeritus
SECTION 101. SHORT TITLE 4
SECTION 102. DEFINITIONS 4
SECTION 103. SCOPE; EXCLUSIONS 41
SECTION 104. MIXED TRANSACTIONS: AGREEMENT TO OPT-IN OR OPT-OUT 58
SECTION 105. RELATION TO FEDERAL LAW; FUNDAMENTAL PUBLIC POLICY;
TRANSACTIONS SUBJECT TO OTHER STATE LAW 62
SECTION 106. RULES OF CONSTRUCTION 70
SECTION 107. LEGAL RECOGNITION OF ELECTRONIC RECORD AND AUTHENTICATION;
USE OF ELECTRONIC AGENTS 72
SECTION 108. PROOF AND EFFECT OF AUTHENTICATION 74
SECTION 109. CHOICE OF LAW 75
SECTION 110. CONTRACTUAL CHOICE OF FORUM 79
SECTION 111. UNCONSCIONABLE CONTRACT OR TERM 80
SECTION 112. MANIFESTING ASSENT; OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW 82
SECTION 113. VARIATION BY AGREEMENT; COMMERCIAL PRACTICE 92
SECTION 114. SUPPLEMENTAL PRINCIPLES; GOOD FAITH; DECISION FOR COURT;
REASONABLE TIME; REASON TO KNOW 95
SECTION 201. FORMAL REQUIREMENTS 100
SECTION 202. FORMATION IN GENERAL 106
SECTION 203. OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE IN GENERAL 109
SECTION 204. ACCEPTANCE WITH VARYING TERMS 111
SECTION 205. CONDITIONAL OFFER OR ACCEPTANCE 114
SECTION 206. OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE: ELECTRONIC AGENTS 116
SECTION 207. FORMATION: RELEASES OF INFORMATIONAL RIGHTS 118
SECTION 208. ADOPTING TERMS OF RECORDS 120
SECTION 209. MASS-MARKET LICENSE 123
SECTION 210. TERMS OF CONTRACT FORMED BY CONDUCT 128
SECTION 211. PRETRANSACTION DISCLOSURES IN INTERNET-TYPE TRANSACTIONS 131
SECTION 212. EFFICACY AND COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS OF ATTRIBUTION
PROCEDURE 133
SECTION 213. DETERMINING ATTRIBUTION 135
SECTION 214. ELECTRONIC ERROR: CONSUMER DEFENSES 138
SECTION 215. ELECTRONIC MESSAGE: WHEN EFFECTIVE; EFFECT OF
ACKNOWLEDGMENT 141
SECTION 216. IDEA OR INFORMATION SUBMISSION 143
SECTION 301. PAROL OR EXTRINSIC EVIDENCE 146
SECTION 302. PRACTICAL CONSTRUCTION 148
SECTION 303. MODIFICATION AND RESCISSION 150
SECTION 304. CONTINUING CONTRACTUAL TERMS 153
SECTION 305. TERMS TO BE SPECIFIED 157
SECTION 306. PERFORMANCE UNDER OPEN TERMS 158
SECTION 307. INTERPRETATION AND REQUIREMENTS FOR GRANT 160
SECTION 308. DURATION OF CONTRACT 165
SECTION 309. AGREEMENT FOR PERFORMANCE TO PARTY'S SATISFACTION 168
SECTION 401. WARRANTY AND OBLIGATIONS CONCERNING NONINTERFERENCE
AND NONINFRINGEMENT 171
SECTION 402. EXPRESS WARRANTY 178
SECTION 403. IMPLIED WARRANTY: MERCHANTABILITY OF COMPUTER PROGRAM 183
SECTION 404. IMPLIED WARRANTY: INFORMATIONAL CONTENT 187
SECTION 405. IMPLIED WARRANTY: LICENSEE'S PURPOSE; SYSTEM INTEGRATION 191
SECTION 406. DISCLAIMER OR MODIFICATION OF WARRANTY 195
SECTION 407. MODIFICATION OF COMPUTER PROGRAM 201
SECTION 408. CUMULATION AND CONFLICT OF WARRANTIES 202
SECTION 409. THIRD-PARTY BENEFICIARIES OF WARRANTY 203
SECTION 501. OWNERSHIP OF INFORMATIONAL RIGHTS 206
SECTION 502. TITLE TO COPY 207
SECTION 503. TRANSFER OF CONTRACTUAL INTEREST 210
SECTION 504. EFFECT OF TRANSFER OF CONTRACTUAL INTEREST 215
SECTION 505. PERFORMANCE BY DELEGATE; SUBCONTRACT 217
SECTION 506. TRANSFER BY LICENSEE 218
SECTION 507. FINANCING IF FINANCIER DOES NOT BECOME LICENSEE 220
SECTION 508. FINANCE LICENSES 222
SECTION 509. FINANCING ARRANGEMENTS: OBLIGATIONS IRREVOCABLE 225
SECTION 510. FINANCING ARRANGEMENTS: REMEDIES OR ENFORCEMENT 226
SECTION 511. FINANCING ARRANGEMENTS: EFFECT ON LICENSOR'S RIGHTS 229
SECTION 601. PERFORMANCE OF CONTRACT IN GENERAL 231
SECTION 602. LICENSOR'S OBLIGATIONS TO ENABLE USE 234
SECTION 603. SUBMISSIONS OF INFORMATION TO SATISFACTION OF PARTY 236
SECTION 604. IMMEDIATELY COMPLETED PERFORMANCE 238
SECTION 605. ELECTRONIC REGULATION OF PERFORMANCE 239
SECTION 606. COPY: DELIVERY; TENDER OF DELIVERY 243
SECTION 607. COPY: PERFORMANCE RELATED TO DELIVERY; PAYMENT 246
SECTION 608. COPY: RIGHT TO INSPECT; PAYMENT BEFORE INSPECTION 248
SECTION 609. COPY: WHEN ACCEPTANCE OCCURS 250
SECTION 610. COPY: EFFECT OF ACCEPTANCE; BURDEN OF ESTABLISHING; NOTICE
OF CLAIMS 253
SECTION 611. ACCESS CONTRACTS 255
SECTION 612. CORRECTION AND SUPPORT CONTRACTS 259
SECTION 613. CONTRACTS INVOLVING PUBLISHERS, DEALERS, AND END USERS 261
SECTION 614. RISK OF LOSS OF COPY 265
SECTION 615. EXCUSE BY FAILURE OF PRESUPPOSED CONDITIONS 267
SECTION 616. TERMINATION: SURVIVAL OF OBLIGATIONS 270
SECTION 617. NOTICE OF TERMINATION 272
SECTION 618. TERMINATION: ENFORCEMENT 275
SECTION 701. BREACH OF CONTRACT; MATERIAL BREACH 277
SECTION 702. WAIVER OF REMEDY FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT 280
SECTION 703. CURE OF BREACH OF CONTRACT 283
SECTION 704. COPY: REFUSAL OF DEFECTIVE TENDER 287
SECTION 705. COPY: CONTRACT WITH PREVIOUS VESTED GRANT OF RIGHTS 290
SECTION 706. COPY: DUTIES UPON RIGHTFUL REFUSAL 291
SECTION 707. COPY: REVOCATION OF ACCEPTANCE 295
SECTION 708. ADEQUATE ASSURANCE OF PERFORMANCE 297
SECTION 709. ANTICIPATORY REPUDIATION 299
SECTION 710. RETRACTION OF ANTICIPATORY REPUDIATION 299
SECTION 801. REMEDIES IN GENERAL 301
SECTION 802. CANCELLATION 302
SECTION 803. CONTRACTUAL MODIFICATION OF REMEDY 306
SECTION 804. LIQUIDATION OF DAMAGES 311
SECTION 805. LIMITATION OF ACTIONS 312
SECTION 806. REMEDIES FOR FRAUD 316
SECTION 807. MEASUREMENT OF DAMAGES IN GENERAL 316
SECTION 808. LICENSOR'S DAMAGES 320
SECTION 809. LICENSEE'S DAMAGES 325
SECTION 810. RECOUPMENT 330
SECTION 811. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE 331
SECTION 812. COMPLETING PERFORMANCE 333
SECTION 813. CONTINUING USE 334
SECTION 814. DISCONTINUING ACCESS 335
SECTION 815. RIGHT TO POSSESSION AND TO PREVENT USE 336
SECTION 816. LIMITATIONS ON ELECTRONIC SELF-HELP 338
SECTION 901. SEVERABILITY 345
SECTION 902. EFFECTIVE DATE 345
SECTION 903. REPEALS 345
SECTION 904. PREVIOUS RIGHTS AND TRANSACTIONS 345
SECTION 905. ELECTRONIC SIGNATURES IN GLOBAL AND NATIONAL COMMERCE
ACT 345
Once land ownership and agrarian production were primary sources of wealth and income in our economy, and contracts for the exchange of horses and grain dominated the commercial landscape. Following the industrial revolution, manufactured goods assumed center stage. In the 1930s Llewellyn recognized that this change required revisions to the law of sales, so that its rules were relevant to the new economy. The result was UCC Article 2. Despite initially strong resistance, Article 2 won universal acceptance, for it reflected the reality of economic change and its implications for contract law.
Our economy has experienced another fundamental change, with information products and services now driving increased productivity and growth. Accompanying this change is a widely diverse and rich array of methods for distributing and tailoring digital information to the modern marketplace. Contracts underlie both the creation and distribution of such information. However, legal rules that are not relevant to commercial practice or that are uncertain in application inhibit contracting or raise transaction costs. UCITA was drafted in response to this fundamental economic change and need for clarity in the law.
Article 2 served as both a model and a point of departure for UCITA. Like Article 2, UCITA covers a variety of transactions, many of which take place solely between merchants. Article 2 governs sales of jet planes as well as toasters, not to mention the large-scale acquisition of jet and toaster parts. UCITA governs access by Fortune 500 businesses to sophisticated databases as well as distribution of software to the general public; it also covers custom software development and the acquisition of various rights in multimedia products.
Both UCITA and Article 2 are based upon the principle of freedom of contract: with limited exceptions, the terms and effect of a contract can be varied by agreement. Most provisions of both statutes are default rules, applicable only if the parties do not specify some other rule. Although one could try to fashion a contract code that regulates comprehensively rather than permitting such flexibility, it is hard to imagine such an approach being compatible with a vibrant market economy. Even if one succeeded in making the regulations stick, the effect would be to hinder rather than facilitate commerce. On the other hand, as noted, without certain default rules, contracting and thus legal rights remain unclear.
To be sure, not every contract should be enforced. UCITA follows Article 2 in providing a standard of unconscionability for courts to employ in policing contract terms. UCITA goes beyond Article 2 in authorizing courts to strike down over-reaching language that conflicts with fundamental public policy. UCITA provides that common law doctrines such as fraud and duress remain effective. UCITA does not alter competition or antitrust law. It does not change trade secret law, intellectual property law, or substantive consumer law. It deals only with contracts.
As Llewellyn recognized in drafting Article 2, contract law must be tailored to the type of transactions that it covers. Just as a body of law based on images of the sale of horses was not relevant a half century ago to sales of manufactured goods, so today a body of law based on images of the sale of manufactured goods ill fits licenses and other transactions in computer information. Rules based on an antiquated view of the transactional world do not give coherent guidance to courts or to transacting parties.
UCITA is the first uniform contract law designed to deal specifically with the new information economy. Transactions in computer information involve different expectations, different industry practices, and different policies from transactions in goods. For example, in a sale of goods, the buyer owns what it buys and has exclusive rights in that subject matter (e.g., the toaster that has been purchased). In contrast, someone that acquires a copy of computer information may or may not own that copy, but in any case rarely obtains all rights associated with the information. See DSC Communications Corp. v. Pulse Communications, Inc., 170 F.3d 1354 (Fed. Cir. 1999). What rights are acquired or withheld depends on what the contract says. This point only is implicit in Article 2 for goods such as books; UCITA makes it explicit for the information economy where, unlike in the case of a book, the contract (license) is the product.
Licensing is one way in which computer information is tailored to the information marketplace. Courts have enforced contract terms that, among other things:
| • preclude commercial use | • permit commercial use |
| • preclude making copies | • permit making multiple copies |
| • grant access | • limit access |
| • allow use throughout a site | • limit use to a specific computer |
| • preclude distribution of copies for a fee | • allow distribution of copies |
| • preclude modification | • allow modification |
| • allow distribution only in specific way | • limit use to internal operations |
Such contract terms have helped to create the wondrous array of products and services that characterizes our modern economy. Whether specific terms are appropriate for a given transaction or set of parties is fundamentally a marketplace issue.
As noted, in computer information transactions, license terms often define the product. A software product may be provided in the same form in two transactions, but in one case the user is authorized to make 100,000 copies and in the other merely to use a single copy at home. The value of the transaction inheres not in the tangible medium (if, indeed, any is used), but rather in the license grant terms. UCITA does not require that computer information products and services be licensed; it covers sales as well. But UCITA provides a coherent contract law framework for analyzing a license, which has been the dominant contractual framework for commerce in computer information.
Up to this point, a complex mix of common law and Article 2 has governed computer information transactions. The common law is frequently difficult to ascertain, and it varies widely among States. In addition, differences in the legal norms that have developed in different areas of information practice are producing unpredictable results as those areas converge. Article 2, while uniform, does not properly apply to many issues involved in transactions in computer information, and when it applies, it often does not provide appropriate guidance because of differences in subject matter and transactional frameworks.
The need for a coherent, uniform body of law has never been greater. Revolutions in telecommunications and computer technology have made geography increasingly irrelevant to modern commerce. The Internet enables small firms as well as large ones to provide products and services throughout the country and around the world. Even as online systems have altered how many information transactions are performed, however, fundamental issues associated with contracting online remain unanswered. A modern contract law must give guidance on those issues. Failure to do so does not foster but rather impedes commerce in computer information.
The liberating promise of technology cannot be fully realized unless there is predictability in the legal rules that govern such transactions. This is the need that UCITA addresses. It clarifies and sets forth uniform legal principles applicable to computer information transactions. UCITA is a statute for our time.
SECTION 101. SHORT TITLE. This [Act] may be cited as the Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act.
SECTION 102. DEFINITIONS.
(a) In this [Act]:
(1) "Access contract" means a contract to obtain by electronic means access to, or information from, an information processing system of another person, or the equivalent of such access.
(2) "Access material" means any information or material, such as a document, address, or access code, that is necessary to obtain authorized access to information or control or possession of a copy.
(3) "Aggrieved party" means a party entitled to a remedy for breach of contract.
(4) "Agreement" means the bargain of the parties in fact as found in their language or by implication from other circumstances, including course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade as provided in this [Act].
(5) "Attribution procedure" means a procedure to verify that an electronic authentication, display, message, record, or performance is that of a particular person or to detect changes or errors in information. The term includes a procedure that requires the use of algorithms or other codes, identifying words or numbers, encryption, or callback or other acknowledgment.
(6) "Authenticate" means:
(A) to sign; or
(B) with the intent to sign a record, otherwise to execute or adopt an electronic symbol, sound, message, or process referring to, attached to, included in, or logically associated or linked with, that record.
(7) "Automated transaction" means a transaction in which a contract is formed in whole or part by electronic actions of one or both parties which are not previously reviewed by an individual in the ordinary course.
(8) "Cancellation" means the ending of a contract by a party because of breach of contract by another party.
(9) "Computer" means an electronic device that accepts information in digital or similar form and manipulates it for a result based on a sequence of instructions.
(10) "Computer information" means information in electronic form which is obtained from or through the use of a computer or which is in a form capable of being processed by a computer. The term includes a copy of the information and any documentation or packaging associated with the copy.
(11) "Computer information transaction" means an agreement or the performance of it to create, modify, transfer, or license computer information or informational rights in computer information. The term includes a support contract under Section 612. The term does not include a transaction merely because the parties' agreement provides that their communications about the transaction will be in the form of computer information.
(12) "Computer program" means a set of statements or instructions to be used directly or indirectly in a computer to bring about a certain result. The term does not include separately identifiable informational content.
(13) "Consequential damages" resulting from breach of contract includes (i) any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the breaching party at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented and (ii) any injury to an individual or damage to property other than the subject matter of the transaction proximately resulting from breach of warranty. The term does not include direct damages or incidental damages.
(14) "Conspicuous", with reference to a term, means so written, displayed, or presented that a reasonable person against which it is to operate ought to have noticed it. A term in an electronic record intended to evoke a response by an electronic agent is conspicuous if it is presented in a form that would enable a reasonably configured electronic agent to take it into account or react to it without review of the record by an individual. Conspicuous terms include the following:
(A) with respect to a person:
(i) a heading in capitals in a size equal to or greater than, or in contrasting type, font, or color to, the surrounding text;
(ii) language in the body of a record or display in larger or other contrasting type, font, or color or set off from the surrounding text by symbols or other marks that draw attention to the language; and
(iii) a term prominently referenced in an electronic record or display which is readily accessible or reviewable from the record or display; and
(B) with respect to a person or an electronic agent, a term or reference to a term that is so placed in a record or display that the person or electronic agent cannot proceed without taking action with respect to the particular term or reference.
(15) "Consumer" means an individual who is a licensee of information or informational rights that the individual at the time of contracting intended to be used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes. The term does not include an individual who is a licensee primarily for professional or commercial purposes, including agriculture, business management, and investment management other than management of the individual's personal or family investments.
(16) "Consumer contract" means a contract between a merchant licensor and a consumer.
(17) "Contract" means the total legal obligation resulting from the parties' agreement as affected by this [Act] and other applicable law.
(18) "Contract fee" means the price, fee, rent, or royalty payable in a contract under this [Act] or any part of the amount payable.
(19) "Contractual use term" means an enforceable term that defines or limits the use, disclosure of, or access to licensed information or informational rights, including a term that defines the scope of a license.
(20) "Copy" means the medium on which information is fixed on a temporary or permanent basis and from which it can be perceived, reproduced, used, or communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device.
(21) "Course of dealing" means a sequence of previous conduct between the parties to a particular transaction which establishes a common basis of understanding for interpreting their expressions and other conduct.
(22) "Course of performance" means repeated performances, under a contract that involves repeated occasions for performance, which are accepted or acquiesced in without objection by a party having knowledge of the nature of the performance and an opportunity to object to it.
(23) "Court" includes an arbitration or other dispute-resolution forum if the parties have agreed to use of that forum or its use is required by law.
(24) "Delivery", with respect to a copy, means the voluntary physical or electronic transfer of possession or control.
(25) "Direct damages" means compensation for losses measured by Section 808(b)(1) or 809(a)(1). The term does not include consequential damages or incidental damages.
(26) "Electronic" means relating to technology having electrical, digital, magnetic, wireless, optical, electromagnetic, or similar capabilities.
(27) "Electronic agent" means a computer program, or electronic or other automated means, used independently to initiate an action, or to respond to electronic messages or performances, on the person's behalf without review or action by an individual at the time of the action or response to the message or performance.
(28) "Electronic message" means a record or display that is stored, generated, or transmitted by electronic means for the purpose of communication to another person or electronic agent.
(29) "Financial accommodation contract" means an agreement under which a person extends a financial accommodation to a licensee and which does not create a security interest governed by [Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code]. The agreement may be in any form, including a license or lease.
(30) "Financial services transaction" means an agreement that provides for, or a transaction that is, or entails access to, use, transfer, clearance, settlement, or processing of:
(A) a deposit, loan, funds, or monetary value represented in electronic form and stored or capable of storage by electronic means and retrievable and transferable by electronic means, or other right to payment to or from a person;
(B) an instrument or other item;
(C) a payment order, credit card transaction, debit card transaction, funds transfer, automated clearinghouse transfer, or similar wholesale or retail transfer of funds;
(D) a letter of credit, document of title, financial asset, investment property, or similar asset held in a fiduciary or agency capacity; or
(E) related identifying, verifying, access-enabling, authorizing, or monitoring information.
(31) "Financier" means a person that provides a financial accommodation to a licensee under a financial accommodation contract and either (i) becomes a licensee for the purpose of transferring or sublicensing the license to the party to which the financial accommodation is provided or (ii) obtains a contractual right under the financial accommodation contract to preclude the licensee's use of the information or informational rights under a license in the event of breach of the financial accommodation contract. The term does not include a person that selects, creates, or supplies the information that is the subject of the license, owns the informational rights in the information, or provides support for, modifications to, or maintenance of the information.
(32) "Good faith" means honesty in fact and the observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing.
(33) "Goods" means all things that are movable at the time relevant to the computer information transaction. The term includes the unborn young of animals, growing crops, and other identified things to be severed from realty which are covered by [Section 2-107 of the Uniform Commercial Code]. The term does not include computer information, money, the subject matter of foreign exchange transactions, documents, letters of credit, letter-of-credit rights, instruments, investment property, accounts, chattel paper, deposit accounts, or general intangibles.
(34) "Incidental damages" resulting from breach of contract:
(A) means compensation for any commercially reasonable charges, expenses, or commissions reasonably incurred by an aggrieved party with respect to:
(i) inspection, receipt, transmission, transportation, care, or custody of identified copies or information that is the subject of the breach;
(ii) stopping delivery, shipment, or transmission;
(iii) effecting cover or retransfer of copies or information after the breach;
(iv) other efforts after the breach to minimize or avoid loss resulting from the breach; and
(v) matters otherwise incident to the breach; and
(B) does not include consequential damages or direct damages.
(35) "Information" means data, text, images, sounds, mask works, or computer programs, including collections and compilations of them.
(36) "Information processing system" means an electronic system for creating, generating, sending, receiving, storing, displaying, or processing information.
(37) "Informational content" means information that is intended to be communicated to or perceived by an individual in the ordinary use of the information, or the equivalent of that information.
(38) "Informational rights" include all rights in information created under laws governing patents, copyrights, mask works, trade secrets, trademarks, publicity rights, or any other law that gives a person, independently of contract, a right to control or preclude another person's use of or access to the information on the basis of the rights holder's interest in the information.
(39) "Insurance services transaction" means an agreement between an insurer and an insured which provides for, or a transaction that is, or entails access to, use, transfer, clearance, settlement, or processing of:
(A) an insurance policy, contract, or certificate; or
(B) a right to payment under an insurance policy, contract, or certificate.
(40) "Knowledge", with respect to a fact, means actual knowledge of the fact.
(41) "License" means a contract that authorizes access to, or use, distribution, performance, modification, or reproduction of, information or informational rights, but expressly limits the access or uses authorized or expressly grants fewer than all rights in the information, whether or not the transferee has title to a licensed copy. The term includes an access contract, a lease of a computer program, and a consignment of a copy. The term does not include a reservation or creation of a security interest to the extent the interest is governed by [Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code].
(42) "Licensee" means a person entitled by agreement to acquire or exercise rights in, or to have access to or use of, computer information under an agreement to which this [Act] applies. A licensor is not a licensee with respect to rights reserved to it under the agreement.
(43) "Licensor" means a person obligated by agreement to transfer or create rights in, or to give access to or use of, computer information or informational rights in it under an agreement to which this [Act] applies. Between the provider of access and a provider of the informational content to be accessed, the provider of content is the licensor. In an exchange of information or informational rights, each party is a licensor with respect to the information, informational rights, or access it gives.
(44) "Mass-market license" means a standard form used in a mass-market transaction.
(45) "Mass-market transaction" means a transaction that is:
(A) a consumer contract; or
(B) any other transaction with an end-user licensee if:
(i) the transaction is for information or informational rights directed to the general public as a whole, including consumers, under substantially the same terms for the same information;
(ii) the licensee acquires the information or informational rights in a retail transaction under terms and in a quantity consistent with an ordinary transaction in a retail market; and
(iii) the transaction is not:
(I) a contract for redistribution or for public performance or public display of a copyrighted work;
(II) a transaction in which the information is customized or otherwise specially prepared by the licensor for the licensee, other than minor customization using a capability of the information intended for that purpose;
(III) a site license; or
(IV) an access contract.
(46) "Merchant" means a person:
(A) that deals in information or informational rights of the kind involved in the transaction;
(B) that by the person's occupation holds itself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to the relevant aspect of the business practices or information involved in the transaction; or
(C) to which the knowledge or skill peculiar to the practices or information involved in the transaction may be attributed by the person's employment of an agent or broker or other intermediary that by its occupation holds itself out as having the knowledge or skill.
(47) "Nonexclusive license" means a license that does not preclude the licensor from transferring to other licensees the same information, informational rights, or contractual rights within the same scope. The term includes a consignment of a copy.
(48) "Notice" of a fact means knowledge of the fact, receipt of notification of the fact, or reason to know the fact exists.
(49) "Notify", or "give notice", means to take such steps as may be reasonably required to inform the other person in the ordinary course, whether or not the other person actually comes to know of it.
(50) "Party" means a person that engages in a transaction or makes an agreement under this [Act].
(51) "Person" means an individual, corporation, business trust, estate, trust, partnership, limited liability company, association, joint venture, governmental subdivision, instrumentality, or agency, public corporation, or any other legal or commercial entity.
(52) "Published informational content" means informational content prepared for or made available to recipients generally, or to a class of recipients, in substantially the same form. The term does not include informational content that is:
(A) customized for a particular recipient by one or more individuals acting as or on behalf of the licensor, using judgment or expertise; or
(B) provided in a special relationship of reliance between the provider and the recipient.
(53) "Receipt" means:
(A) with respect to a copy, taking delivery; or
(B) with respect to a notice:
(i) coming to a person's attention; or
(ii) being delivered to and available at a location or system designated by agreement for that purpose or, in the absence of an agreed location or system:
(I) being delivered at the person's residence, or the person's place of business through which the contract was made, or at any other place held out by the person as a place for receipt of communications of the kind; or
(II) in the case of an electronic notice, coming into existence in an information processing system or at an address in that system in a form capable of being processed by or perceived from a system of that type by a recipient, if the recipient uses, or otherwise has designated or holds out, that place or system for receipt of notices of the kind to be given and the sender does not know that the notice cannot be accessed from that place.
(54) "Receive" means to take receipt.
(55) "Record" means information that is inscribed on a tangible medium or that is stored in an electronic or other medium and is retrievable in perceivable form.
(56) "Release" means an agreement by a party not to object to, or exercise any rights or pursue any remedies to limit, the use of information or informational rights which agreement does not require an affirmative act by the party to enable or support the other party's use of the information or informational rights. The term includes a waiver of informational rights.
(57) "Return", with respect to a record containing contractual terms that were rejected, refers only to the computer information and means:
(A) in the case of a licensee that rejects a record regarding a single information product transferred for a single contract fee, a right to reimbursement of the contract fee paid from the person to which it was paid or from another person that offers to reimburse that fee, on:
(i) submission of proof of purchase; and
(ii) proper redelivery of the computer information and all copies within a reasonable time after initial delivery of the information to the licensee;
(B) in the case of a licensee that rejects a record regarding an information product provided as part of multiple information products integrated into and transferred as a bundled whole but retaining their separate identity:
(i) a right to reimbursement of any portion of the aggregate contract fee identified by the licensor in the initial transaction as charged to the licensee for all bundled information products which was actually paid, on:
(I) rejection of the record before or during the initial use of the bundled product;
(II) proper redelivery of all computer information products in the bundled whole and all copies of them within a reasonable time after initial delivery of the information to the licensee; and
(III) submission of proof of purchase; or
(ii) a right to reimbursement of any separate contract fee identified by the licensor in the initial transaction as charged to the licensee for the separate information product to which the rejected record applies, on:
(I) submission of proof of purchase; and
(II) proper redelivery of that computer information product and all copies within a reasonable time after initial delivery of the information to the licensee; or
(C) in the case of a licensor that rejects a record proposed by the licensee, a right to proper redelivery of the computer information and all copies from the licensee, to stop delivery or access to the information by the licensee, and to reimbursement from the licensee of amounts paid by the licensor with respect to the rejected record, on reimbursement to the licensee of contract fees that it paid with respect to the rejected record, subject to recoupment and setoff.
(58) "Scope", with respect to terms of a license, means:
(A) the licensed copies, information, or informational rights involved;
(B) the use or access authorized, prohibited, or controlled;
(C) the geographic area, market, or location; or
(D) the duration of the license.
(59) "Seasonable", with respect to an act, means taken within the time agreed or, if no time is agreed, within a reasonable time.
(60) "Send" means, with any costs provided for and properly addressed or directed as reasonable under the circumstances or as otherwise agreed, to deposit a record in the mail or with a commercially reasonable carrier, to deliver a record for transmission to or re-creation in another location or information processing system, or to take the steps necessary to initiate transmission to or re-creation of a record in another location or information processing system. In addition, with respect to an electronic message, the message must be in a form capable of being processed by or perceived from a system of the type the recipient uses or otherwise has designated or held out as a place for the receipt of communications of the kind sent. Receipt within the time in which it would have arrived if properly sent, has the effect of a proper sending.
(61) "Standard form" means a record or a group of related records containing terms prepared for repeated use in transactions and so used in a transaction in which there was no negotiated change of terms by individuals except to set the price, quantity, method of payment, selection among standard options, or time or method of delivery.
(62) "State" means a State of the United States, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the Unites States Virgin Islands, or any territory or insular possession subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.
(63) "Term", with respect to an agreement, means that portion of the agreement which relates to a particular matter.
(64) "Termination" means the ending of a contract by a party pursuant to a power created by agreement or law otherwise than because of breach of contract.
(65) "Transfer":
(A) with respect to a contractual interest, includes an assignment of the contract, but does not include an agreement merely to perform a contractual obligation or to exercise contractual rights through a delegate or sublicensee; and
(B) with respect to computer information, includes a sale, license, or lease of a copy of the computer information and a license or assignment of informational rights in computer information.
(66) "Usage of trade" means any practice or method of dealing that has such regularity of observance in a place, vocation, or trade as to justify an expectation that it will be observed with respect to the transaction in question.
(b) The following definitions in [the Uniform Commercial Code (1998 Official Text)] apply to this [Act]:
(1) "Burden of establishing" [Section 1-201]
(2) "Document of title" [Section 1-201].
(3) "Financial asset" [Section 8-102(a)(9)].
(4) "Funds transfer" [Section 4A-104].
(5) "Identification" to the contract [Section 2-501].
(6) "Instrument" [Section 9-105(i) (1995 Official Text) or 9-102(a)(47) (1998 Official Text)].
(7) "Investment property" [Section 9-115(f) (1995 Official Text) or 9-102(a)(49) (1998 Official Text)].
(8) "Item" [Section 4-104].
(9) "Letter of credit" [Section 5-102].
(10) "Payment order" [Section 4A-103].
(11) "Sale" [Section 2-106].
Legislative note: If your State's definition differs from the 1998 Official Text, include the definition from the Official Text in subsection (a).
1. "Access contract." An access contract is an agreement that authorizes access to, or obtaining information from, an electronic facility, including a computer or Internet site, or that allows an equivalent form of access. The term does not include contracts that merely grant a right to enter a building or other physical location that contains information, or the mere purchase of a television, radio, or similar goods that merely create technological ability to access information.
An "access contract" is typified by "on-line" services. It also includes contracts for remote data processing, remote access to applications software or data stored on a third party computer, third party e-mail systems, and contracts for automatic updating from a remote facility to a database held by the licensee. The term does not cover interactions among computer programs within a person's own system - the access must be to another person's system or data. Thus, if a licensee of a spreadsheet program uses it to interact with the licensee's computers and data on the licensee's own network, that is not an access contract. However, a person can provide the equivalent of access, and thereby create an access contract, even though the information is only used on the licensee's system, such as where an on-line data provider elects to provide access to data in part by allowing its database to be loaded into the computer of a client. This performance retains all characteristics of an access contract and is within the definition. The same is true if a database loaded into the user's system is intermittently updated with data from remote systems. On the other hand, if a software publisher downloads licensed software into a licensee's system, the continuing right to use the software after it is downloaded is not an access contract.
An access provider may, or may not, provide contractual rights in the information accessed. Some transactions entail a three-party framework: in addition to the customer, one licensor provides access, while another (the content provider) licenses the information. This transaction involves two and, in some cases, three contracts. The first is between the content provider and the access provider. The second is between the access provider and the end user. The third arises if the content provider contracts directly with the end user; that too is an access contract. The contracts are independent of each other.
ATM cards, "smart cards," home banking products, and the like enable a customer to obtain information from an information processing system maintained by a financial institution, and would therefore reflect "access contracts" were they not excluded by Section 103(d)(1) as a "financial services transaction" (excludes "related identifying, verifying, access-enabling, authorizing or monitoring information"). Under Section 104, the parties may agree to use the contract formation provisions of this Act to enter into the initial customer relationship and thereafter to obtain an ATM card, smart card, or home banking software. They may further agree that the licensing aspects of their relationship will be governed by this Act. If so, the agreement is an "access contract." The agreement does not subject any transaction effected through use of an ATM card or home banking product to this Act, or alter the rules that would otherwise apply to such transaction.
2. "Agreement". This definition derives from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(3) (1998 Official Text). The term includes full recognition of usage of trade, course of dealing, course of performance and the surrounding circumstances as effective parts of an agreement. The meaning of the agreement is determined by the language the parties use and their actions, interpreted in the light of commercial practice and other surrounding circumstances. See Section 113(b); Section 301 (parol evidence rule). Whether an agreement has legal effect is determined by this Act or other applicable law. Section 114(d).
3. "Attribution procedure." An "attribution procedure" is a procedure used to identify the person who sent an electronic message or to verify the integrity of its content. In general, an attribution procedure has substantive effect only if it was agreed to or adopted by the parties or established by applicable law. Agreement to or adoption of a procedure may occur directly between the two parties or through a third party. For example, the operator of a system that includes information provided by third parties may arrange with database providers and customers for use of a particular attribution procedure. Those arrangements establish an attribution procedure between the customers and the database providers. An attribution procedure may also be established by two parties in the expectation that a third party may rely on it. For example, a digital signature may be issued to an individual pursuant to an agreement between the issuer and the individual, but then accepted or relied on by another party in a separate transaction. Use of the signature is an attribution procedure in that transaction. Similarly, a group of member companies may establish attribution procedures intended to bind members in dealing with one another. Such arrangements are attribution procedures under this Act. The substantive provisions on attribution are in Sections 108, 212, and 213.
4. "Authenticate." This term replaces "signature" and "signed." A similar change in terminology is made in Uniform Commercial Code Article 9 (1998 Official Text). In this Act, the term "sign" has the meaning used in Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201 (1998 Official Text), except that it is not limited to authenticating a writing. The definition is technologically neutral. The definition makes clear that qualifying electronic systems fulfill former paper-based requirements. This is consistent with the policies of the federal Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act which precludes discrimination against electronic records and signatures solely because they are electronic in character.
Any "signature" under other law is an authentication under this Act. In addition, authentication includes qualifying use of any identifier, such as a personal identification number (PIN) or a typed or otherwise signed name. It can include actions or sounds such as encryption, voice and biological identification, and other technologically enabled acts if done with proper intent. See Parma Tile Mosaic & Marble Co. v. Short, 663 N.E.2d 633 (N.Y. 1996) (intent requirement not met). There is no requirement that the authenticated record be retained by a party unless that requirement exists under other law.
An authentication may be on, logically associated with, or linked to the record. With digital technology, the analogy between signing a record electronically and signing a paper is not precise. "Logically associated" makes it clear that the association between an authentication and a record need not be physical in nature. However, the association must support the inference that the authenticating party intends to adopt or accept the associated or referenced record. "Referring to" or "linked to" captures the traditional concept of incorporating a record or term by reference, as well as use of an electronic connection, such as an Internet hyperlink.
An "authentication" may express various intended effects. What effects are intended are determined by the context and objective indicia associated with that context.
5. "Automated transaction." This term refers to contracts formed automatically and which are effective even though one or both parties operates through an electronic agent instead of a human being (an individual). The term is not inconsistent with a system in which, when an aspect of the transaction appears irregular, or when a message or transaction fails automated system edits, repair or review by an employee occurs. The transaction qualifies as an automated transaction if such review does not occur in the ordinary course when no system problems exist and there was no review in the particular case by an employee authorized to act on behalf of the employer in the particular case.
6. "Cancellation." This definition follows Uniform Commercial Code § 2-106(4) (1998 Official Text); no substantive change is intended by language variations. Cancellation is a remedy for breach. The effect of cancellation is stated in Section 802.
7. "Computer." The definition of "computer" draws on definitions in federal and state criminal law, tax law and other resources. The term does not include a traditional television set, radio or toaster even though such goods may contain a microprocessor. It might include new generations of machines that combine computation, word processing, Internet access, and traditional broadcast reception. The definition should be applied by the courts with common sense. In various States, unauthorized access to a computer is a crime, but while the definition of computer in those statutes is broad, courts exercise common sense in applying the definition, an approach that should also be true here. Thus, while an automobile might contain a computer or several computers, the automobile is not itself a computer. A microwave oven with timing operations controlled by software is not a computer, but ordinary goods enhanced by software. On the other hand, a desktop computer that receives telephone calls or fax messages is still a computer.
8. "Computer information." This term covers information that is in electronic form and that is obtained from, accessible with, or usable by, a computer; it includes the information, the copy of it (e.g., a diskette containing the information), and its documentation (including non-electronic documentation). As defined, "electronic" includes digital information or information in another form having similar capabilities. This covers analog and future computational technologies, eliminating the possibility that the Act might be limited to current technology. The term does not include information merely because it could be scanned or entered into a computer; it is limited to electronic information in a form capable of being directly processed in a computer. "Computer information" does not generally include printed information or other non-electronic formats of information.
9. "Computer information transaction." This term helps establish the scope of this Act. Section 103. It requires an agreement involving computer information. The term includes transfers of computer programs or multimedia products, software and multimedia development contracts, access contracts, and contracts to obtain information for use in a program, access contract, or multimedia product. However, the mere fact that parties agree to communicate in digital form does not bring a transaction within this definition, nor does a decision by one party to use computer information when the contract does not require this. An agreement to use e-mail to communicate about a contract for the shipment of petroleum or to file an application in digital form does not bring the transaction within this definition. A contract for an airline ticket is not a computer information transaction simply because the ticket may be represented in digital form. The subject matter of that agreement is not the computer information, but the service - air transportation. See Comments to Section 103.
A transaction is not for the "creation" of computer information in the sense intended here if the contracted-for activities are merely secretarial, ministerial, or clerical in nature. The computer information must be created (i.e., produced or developed) through some business, professional, artistic, imaginative, or similar effort. Of course, a transaction that otherwise qualifies and that occurs with respect to information already in the form of computer information is within the definition regardless of how the information was put into that form.
10. "Computer program." The first sentence parallels copyright law. 17 U.S.C. § 101 (1998). The second sentence distinguishes between computer programs as operating instructions communicated to a computer and "informational content" communicated to human beings. This distinction parallels that used in discussions of formal programming languages between syntax (grammar) and semantics (meaning). As used in this Act, "computer program" refers to functional and operating aspects of a digital or similar system, whereas "informational content" refers to material that communicates to a person. In resolving an issue that turns on this distinction, the test lies in whether the issue concerns operations (program) or communicated content (informational content). The definition pertains solely to contract law issues. It does not relate to the copyright law issue of distinguishing between a process and copyrightable expression. The distinction here is more like that in copyright law between a computer program as a "literary work" (code) and output as an "audiovisual work" (images, sounds). In copyright, that distinction relates to property and infringement issues. In this Act, the distinction relates to contract law issues such as liability risk and performance obligations.
11. "Consequential damages." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 2-715(2)(1998 Official Text). Except for the clarification regarding "direct damages" and "incidental damages," no change is intended. For example, while the definition does not specifically exclude losses that could be avoided by mitigation through cover or otherwise, a duty to mitigate exists under Section 807. A party can recover compensation only for losses that it could not reasonably have avoided. Of course, the idea of avoidance through reasonable steps such as cover or otherwise must be assessed with due regard to how damages are measured. For example, if recovery is based on lost volume, the damages measure assumes that another transaction is not a substitute for the lost transaction and, thus, the idea of mitigation through a replacement is not germane. See discussion of substitute transactions in Sections 808 and 809.
Consequential damages do not include "direct" or "incidental" damages. Consequential loss includes loss of anticipated benefits as a result of not being able to exploit or rely on the expected contractual performance, such as lost profits of the injured party, lost third-party royalties that would have accrued from a licensee's proper performance, and lost income from wrongful gains realized by another party from misuse of confidential information. Consequential damages also include damage to reputation, loss of privacy, lost value of a trade secret from wrongful disclosure or use, and losses or damage to data or property caused by a breach.
Except as provided in Section 807 or as limited by agreement, consequential damages may be recovered by either party. The losses must be an ordinary and predictable result of the breach and must have been foreseeable. For purposes of damages computation, the term "reason to know" should be interpreted in a manner consistent with cases under Uniform Commercial Code Article 2. For an injured party to recover for economic losses resulting from its special circumstances, the party in breach must have had notice of those circumstances at the time of contracting. In contrast, losses from ordinary, general requirements can often be presumed to have been within the contemplation of the other party. To be foreseeable, the losses must not result from atypical risk taking by the aggrieved party, such as in a failure reasonably to maintain back-up systems for retrieval of data.
Damage to other property (i.e., not the property that is the subject of the contract itself) may be consequential damage. If injury follows use of a computer program without discovery of a defect causing the damage, the question of "proximate" cause includes whether it was reasonable for the injured party to use the information without inspection that would have revealed the defect. Proximate causation may not exist where damages result from misuse or from a use that violates clear warnings against the particular type of use.
12. "Conspicuous." This definition follows Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(10) (1998 Official Text), but is updated for electronic commerce. Whether a term is conspicuous is determined by the court. Section 114. The definition of "conspicuous" does not change requirements of other law that specify the content, timing or location of disclosures or warnings. If such requirements exist, they govern. Sections 105 and 114.
A term is conspicuous if it is so positioned or presented that the attention of an ordinary person reasonably ought to have been called to it. Conspicuous terms are often contained in a record, but the concept includes oral or automated voice presentations that meet the standard. For electronic records, whether a term is conspicuous is gauged by the condition of the message as it would be received or first viewed by a person using a system that the parties adopted for such records, a system that the sender knows the recipient is using or, in the absence of the foregoing, an ordinary system or method of receiving or reviewing such messages. For an electronic agent, presentation of the term must be capable of invoking a response from a reasonably configured electronic agent.
As in Uniform Commercial Code Section 1-201(10) (1998 Official Text), this Act describes several methods of making a term conspicuous. These should be treated as are the analogous illustrations in U.C.C. Article 1. The illustrations are not exclusive. For cases outside their terms, the general standard governs.
The definition adapts the U.C.C. standard to cover electronic commerce. Paragraph (A)(ii) contemplates setting off a term or label by symbols so that conspicuous formatting can be reliably transferred electronically (font size, color and other attributes might not always be transferable). Paragraph (A)(iii) deals with hyperlinks and related Internet technologies. It contemplates a case in which a computer screen displays an image or term or a summary or reference to it, and the party using the screen, by taking an action with reference to it, is promptly transferred to a different display or location wherein the contract term is available. To be conspicuous, the image, term, summary or reference must be prominent and its use must readily enable review of the actual term. The access must be from the display and not require taking other actions such as a telephone call or driving to a store. When the term is accessed, it must be readily reviewable. The fact that an entire contract is prominently referenced does not automatically mean that a particular term in it is conspicuous.
Paragraph (B) is independent of paragraph (A). It recognizes a procedure by which, without taking action with respect to the term or reference, the party cannot proceed. Thus, a screen that states: "There are no warranties of accuracy with respect to the information" in a manner that precludes the user from proceeding without assenting to or rejecting this term, suffices.
13. "Consumer" and "consumer contract." A "consumer" is an individual (human being) who obtains information primarily for personal, household, or family purposes. Whether an individual is a consumer with reference to a transaction is determined at the time of contracting and in light of the then-intended use of the information. For computer information, many contracts for personal use are not consumer contracts (e.g., stock broker personally using software to monitor client investments). The definition distinguishes profit-making, professional, or business use, from non-business or family use. Only when the contract is primarily for the latter is there a consumer contract. A license of software distributed for general personal use and acquired solely for tracking household finances is a consumer contract, but a transaction acquiring software for use in an investment management business is not a consumer transaction. The profit-making standard is followed in other areas of law. See, e.g., Thomas v. Sundance Properties, 726 F.2d 1417 (9th Cir. 1984); In re Booth, 858 F.2d 1051 (5th Cir. 1988); In re Circle Five, Inc., 75 B.R. 686 (Bankr. D. Idaho 1987); Truth in Lending Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1603 (excludes extensions of credit "primarily for business, commercial, or agricultural purposes"). A purpose stated in the agreement ordinarily determines the purpose of the transaction for purposes of this definition.
14. "Contract." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(11) (1998 Official Text).
15. "Contract fee." This term includes any monetary payment under a contract, including royalties. It does not include other forms of consideration exchanged in a transaction or their value.
16. "Contractual use term." This term includes any enforceable contractual term that defines or limits access to, use or disclosure of information or informational rights. Use terms ordinarily relate only to the copies and information provided under the contract or copies made of them. Unless otherwise agreed, a contractual use term does not govern the same information lawfully obtained from other sources. For this definition, the use restriction must come from a contract and not simply from regulatory or property law. The term must be enforceable to be within the definition. Thus, if trade secret law bars enforcement of a particular term, that term is not a contractual use term under this Act to the extent it is unenforceable.
Terms establishing the scope of a license are contractual use terms. Under intellectual property law, however, with respect to determining whether an infringement occurs, not all contract terms are equal. See Sun Microsystems v. Microsoft Corp., 188 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 1999); Schoenberg v. Shappolsky Publishers, Inc., 971 F.2d 926 (2d Cir. 1992). This Act does not alter the distinction with reference to infringement claims. In contract law, however, breach of any contractual use term breaches the contract. Whether there is also a right of action for infringement is determined by other law.
17. "Copy." This term refers to the medium containing the information. The medium can be tangible or electronic. The time when information is fixed on the medium can be temporary if this fulfills the required performance. The copyright law question of when a copy occurs within computer memory or in a transient image does not relate to contract law issues and is not dealt with in this Act. Stenograph v. Bossard, 46 U.S.P.Q.2d 1936 (D.C. Cir. 1998); MAI Systems Corp. v. Peak Computer, Inc., 991 F.2d 511 (9th Cir. 1993).
18. "Course of dealing." This term is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-205 (1998 Official Text). It refers to a sequence of conduct between the parties prior to the agreement at issue.
19. "Course of performance." This term is from Uniform Commercial Code § 2-208 (1998 Official Text). It refers to conduct during performance of the agreement; conduct prior to the agreement may be a "course of dealing". Both terms are part of the commercial approach in this Act to interpreting contracts in a practical manner. The parties know best what their agreement meant; their conduct is often the best indication of that meaning. A course of performance is always relevant to determine the meaning of the agreement. Uniform Commercial Code § 1-205, Comment 2 (1998 Official Text).
20. "Delivery." Delivery can occur by transfer of possession of a tangible copy or by electronic transfer. In electronic delivery, a copy of information may not move from one location to another, but delivery involves copying the information into another location or making it available in a system shared or accessible by the recipient. There are many ways to transfer possession or control. For example, in an electronic delivery, a transfer of possession or control occurs when information comes into existence in an information processing system or at an address in a form capable of being processed by or perceived from a system of that type if the recipient uses, or otherwise has designated or holds out, that place or system for receipt of copies of the kind.
21. "Direct damages." Direct damages are compensation for losses associated with the value of the contracted for performance itself as contrasted to loss of a benefit expected from use of the performance or its results. Direct damages are measured by Sections 808(b) and 809(a). They are capped by the contracted-for price or market value for the performance as appropriate. This Act rejects cases that treat as direct damages losses that relate to anticipated benefits from use such as Chatlos Systems, Inc. v. National Cash Register Corp., 670 F.2d 1304 (3d Cir. 1982). Those are consequential damages. Thus, if a computer program is purchased for $1,000 and, if merchantable, would yield profits or cost-savings in business of $10,000, but it is totally defective, "direct" damages are $1,000. If recoverable, the lost profits or expected cost-savings are consequential damages.
22. "Electronic." This term is technology neutral, and encompasses forms of information-processing technology that may be developed in the future.
23. "Electronic agent." This term refers to an automated means for making or performing contracts. The agent must act independently in a manner relevant to creating or performing a contract. Mere use of a telephone or e-mail system is not use of an electronic agent. The automated system must have been selected, programmed or otherwise intentionally used for that purpose by the person that is bound by its operations. The legal relationship between the person and the electronic agent is not equivalent to common law agency since the "agent" is not a human. However, parties that use electronic agents are ordinarily bound by the results of their operations.
24. "Electronic Message." A message is distinguished from a "record" by the fact that a message is intended for communication to another person or an electronic agent. Communication of a message may be by copying it into another location or making it available in a system shared by or accessible to the recipient. In effect, it is stored or generated for purposes of communicating to another.
25. "Financial accommodation contract." A financial accommodation contract is 1) a loan in whole or in part to acquire computer information or 2) a lease of a copy of software or other computer information. The recipient of the accommodation is the licensee. If a finance contract creates or provides for a security interest governed by Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, the contract is not a "financial accommodation contract"; the interest is governed by Uniform Commercial Code Article 9 and not this Act. Agreements in which royalties for use accrue over time and are paid periodically is not a financial accommodation contract, but simply a royalty-bearing license (or assignment).
26. "Financial services transaction." This term includes a variety of financial system activities and transactions governed under federal and other state law. These are excluded from this Act under Section 103(d). Many are governed by federal law or by the Uniform Commercial Code. The phrase "monetary value represented in electronic form" includes electronic currency. The term "financial services transaction" does not include contracts to acquire software for use in banking or other financial service activities even if the transactions that the software is used to process are financial services transactions that are excluded from the Act. Section 103(d). Nor does it apply to non-regulated information services, such as a virtual mall, provided on the financial institution's website.
27. "Financier." A financier is a creditor or a lessor dealing with the licensee under a financial accommodation contract. The financier may have any of several relationships to licensed computer information. In one the financier obtains rights as a licensee for purposes of transfer to the eventual licensee, which is the accommodated party. This is like a finance lease under Uniform Commercial Code Article 2A, but the focus is licensed computer information, rather than leased goods. A second kind of relationship arises where the party giving the accommodation does not obtain rights in the license as against the licensor, but obtains a contractual right to prevent the licensee's use of the information in the event of breach of the financial accommodation contract.
The licensor in the underlying license is not a financier for purposes of this Act. A licensor may obtain a security interest under Article 9 and would, with respect to that interest, have the rights of a secured party under Article 9.
28. "Good Faith." This definition adopts and expands on Uniform Commercial Code § 2-103(b) (1998 Official Text). It rejects pure "honesty in fact" as the sole standard of good faith. However, good faith is not a negligence or reasonable care standard. "Observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing" is concerned with the fairness of the conduct rather than the care with which an act is performed. Both fair dealing and ordinary reasonable care are judged in light of reasonable commercial standards, but those standards in each case are directed to different aspects of commercial conduct.
While good faith in performance is an element of all contracts covered by this Act, the obligation of good faith does not override express contract terms or the right to enforce them. See Kham & Nates Shoes No. 2, Inc. v. First Bank of Whiting, 908 F.2d 1351 (7th Cir. 1990); Amoco Oil Co. v. Ervin, 908 P.2d 493 (Colo. 1995); Badgett v. Security State Bank, 116 Wn.2d 563, 807 P.2d 356 (1991). The primary application of the concept is that, when a party has discretion under the contract, that discretion should be exercised in a good faith manner. Davis v. Sears, Roebuck & Co., 873 F.2d 888 (6th Cir. 1989). Good faith does not require that a party act to benefit or avoid harm to the other at the cost of rights that it fairly has under the agreement.
29. "Goods." This definition clarifies that computer information, including computer programs, are not goods for purposes of this Act. The definition does not alter the definition of goods in any consumer protection law. Some but not all of the items or transactions treated as financial services transactions in this Act are also excluded from this definition of goods. No inference is intended that those not so excluded, such as payment orders or loans, are thereby treated as goods.
30. "Incidental damages." This term corresponds to Uniform Commercial Code Article 2 (1998 Official Text). Incidental damages are expenses incurred after breach. They include the cost of seeking or arranging for mitigation, but not the actual expenditure for the mitigation itself, which is covered in measuring direct or consequential damages.
31. "Information." This term embraces a wide range of subject matter, but as used in this Act it is limited to transactions within the scope of the Act. "Information" is not limited to subject matter in which informational property rights exist. It includes, for example, factual data if subject to a contractual relationship. As used here, "data" refers to facts whether or not organized or interpreted. A "mask work" is defined in federal law; it refers to a representational technology used in creation of semiconductor products.
32. "Information processing system." This term includes computers and other information processing systems. The term is used primarily in reference to sending and receiving notices.
33. "Informational content." This is information whose ordinary use involves communication of the information to a human being (individual). It is information that humans read, see, hear and otherwise experience. For example, if an electronic database includes images or text and a program enabling display of or access to them, the images are informational content while the search program is not. A Westlaw search program is not informational content, but the text of the cases is. The term applies even if the person creating the informational content does not intend to reveal it to others; this is because preparation involves an intent that the information be perceivable at least by its creator. Informational content need not actually be communicated; it merely must be information that in ordinary use is communicated to individuals. For example, stock quotes are informational content even if an investor uses an electronic agent to make orders and never reads the actual quotes themselves. However, the term does not include computer program instructions in object code that merely control interaction of a computer program with other programs or with a machine or device.
34. "Informational rights." This term includes "intellectual property" rights. It also includes rights created under any law that gives a person a right to control use of information independent of contract, such as may be developing in privacy law. As in traditional intellectual property law, the rights need not be exclusive as to all other persons and all uses. Other law determines whether such rights exist; this Act does not modify those laws. The term does not include mere tort claims such as the right to sue for defamation.
35. "Insurance services transaction." This term parallels that of "financial services transactions" with language changes to reflect the nature of insurance-related transactions. It identifies transactions that are subject to extensive regulation and separately developed law and excludes them because they are regulated. Section 103. It refers to an agreement between the insurer and insured relating to access to, use, transfer, clearance, settlement, or processing of the policy or contract, or payments or rights to payment under it. As with financial services transactions, the term does not include contracts to acquire software, nor does it apply to non-regulated information services, such as a virtual mall, provided on the insurance institution's website.
36. "Knowledge." This term is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(25) (1998 Official Text). It does not include constructive notice or any duty to inquire.
37. "License." A license is an agreement the terms of which entail a limited or conditional transfer of information or a grant of limited or restricted contractual rights or permissions to use information. A contract "right" is an affirmative commitment that a licensee may engage in a specific use, while a contract "permission" means simply that the licensor will not object to the use. Either can be the basis of a license. No specific formality of language is required. For purposes of this Act, the term includes consignments of copies of information but does not otherwise alter the legal nature of a consignment. The definition is solely for purposes of this Act and does not alter treatment under other laws, such as tax law.
A transaction is not a license merely because as a matter of law a transferor retains informational property rights that restrict the transferee's ability to use the information. The term thus does not include an unrestricted sale of a copy of a copyrighted work; an unrestricted sale does not involve express contractual terms restricting use of the information. Similarly, a "copyright notice" in a book that merely states the restrictions on use that remain after a first sale under copyright law is not a license. On the other hand, a software agreement whose terms expressly govern use of the software is a license even if the agreement also gives the licensee ownership of the copy. A license exists if a contract grants greater rights or privileges than a first sale, if it restricts rights or privileges that might otherwise exist, or if it deals with other issues of scope of use.
Whether a contract is a license does not depend on who has title to a copy. Title to a copy is distinct from questions about the extent to which use of information is controlled by contract. DSC v. Pulse Communications, Inc., 170 F.3d 1354 (Fed. Cir. 1999) indicates how the issues can be treated. Restrictions in a license that are materially inconsistent with ownership of a delivered copy may result in the holder of the copy not being its owner.
Licenses are contracts. Whether the terms of a license are enforceable is determined under this Act and other applicable law, including copyright law. The requirements for an enforceable agreement must be met. The term does not include the myriad non-commercial, casual or other exchanges of information that occur in normal political or social discourse, even if there may be incidental restrictions on use of the information because they do not involve a contractual relationship or a computer information transaction.
38. "Licensor" and "Licensee." These definitions refer to the transferor and transferee in any contract covered by this Act, whether or not the contract is a license. In situations where each party supplies computer information to the other, each is a licensor as to the information it provides and a licensee as to the information it receives. Between a provider of access in an access contract and its customer, the provider is the licensor. Between the provider of access and a provider of the information to be accessed, the provider of the information is the licensor.
39. "Mass-market license" and "mass-market transaction." The term "mass market license" is new and the definition must be applied in light of its intended and limited function. That function is to describe small dollar value, routine transactions involving information that is directed to the general public when the transaction occurs in a retail market available to and used by the general public. The term includes all consumer contracts and also some transactions between businesses if they are in a retail market. One purpose of the term is to avoid artificial distinctions among business and consumer transferees in an ordinary retail market. Mass-market transactions do not include commercial transactions between businesses using ordinary commercial methods, such as purchase orders, terms offered to businesses but not to consumers, or online and access systems focused on the business-business marketplace.
A "mass-market" transaction is characterized by 1) the market in which the transaction occurs, 2) the terms of the transaction, and 3) the type of information involved. The market is a retail market where information is made available in pre-packaged form under generally similar terms to the general public as a whole and in which the general public, including consumers, is a frequent participant. "Retail market" has its standard dictionary meaning, which refers to sales (or other transfers) of commodities in small quantities primarily to consumers. The prototypical retail context is a department store, grocery store, gas station, shopping center, or the like. It does not include contexts that center on business-business trade. Retail locations are open to, and in fact attract, the general public as a whole. The products are available to anyone who enters the retail location and pays the standard retail price. While retail merchants make transactions with other businesses, the predominant type of transaction involves consumers. Transactions in a retail market involve small quantities, non-negotiated terms, and transfers to end users rather than transferees who plan to resell or re-license the product. The phrase "in a quantity" is inherent in the idea of retail and emphasizes that the concept involves purchases of small quantities.
The computer information must be of a type aimed at the general public as a whole, including consumers. This does not include information earmarked for a business or professional audience and which is not ordinarily acquired by consumers, nor does it include information earmarked for members of an organization or persons with a separate relationship to the information provider. For example, software provided to and usable only by members of an association or customers of a particular institution, even if otherwise within this Act, are not mass-market transactions. In determining when the term applies, courts should be guided by the purpose of the definition which is to avoid artificial distinctions among business and consumer purchasers in an ordinary retail market. The covered transactions do not include specialty information for business or professional uses, information for specially targeted limited audiences, information distributed in non-retail transactions, or professional use information. The transactions involve computer information routinely acquired by consumers or that tend to appeal to a general public audience as a whole, including consumers. Generally, this is inconsistent with substantial customization of the information for a particular end user. Customization that is routine in mass markets or that is done by the licensee after acquiring the information does not take the transaction outside the concept of a mass-market transaction.
The transaction must be with an end user. An end user is a licensee that intends to use the information or informational rights in its own business or personal affairs. An end user is not engaged in reselling, distributing, sublicensing, commercial public performances of the information, or otherwise making the information commercially available to third parties, directly or indirectly.
All consumer transactions are mass-market. For non-consumer transactions, subsection (B)(iii) expressly excludes several transactions commonly not associated with routine retail transactions. It excludes any transaction intended for redistribution of the information by further license, loan or sale, or for public performance of a copyrighted work. Such transactions involve no attributes of a retail market. For purposes of this Act, public performance or display does not include use by a library patron of software acquired by the library in the mass market. In online contracts, consumer contracts are mass-market transactions, but business to business transactions are not. Business acquisition of software through online access and other non-retail transactions are outside of the definition. This gives electronic commerce room to develop without regulation while preserving consumer interests.
40. "Merchant." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 2-104 (1998 Official Text). The definition covers a person that holds itself out as experienced even if the person has not actually engaged in prior transactions of the type. The term "merchant" has roots in the "law merchant" concept of an expert or professional in business. This status may be based on specialized knowledge as to the information or general or specialized knowledge about business practices, or both. Which type of knowledge is sufficient for merchant status is determined by the nature of the issue to which the term applies. In this Act, as relevant to business practices, "merchant" refers primarily to general knowledge of business practices in any field, rather than to expertise in a specific field. Section 401(a) and (e) and Section 403, however, require a more focused expertise in the particular type of information.
When a party employs an agent, merchant status does not always depend on the principal's knowledge. An organization is charged with the expertise of its employees. Even persons such as universities, for example, can come within the definition of merchant if they have regular purchasing departments or personnel familiar with business practices.
41. "Non-exclusive license." In a nonexclusive license, the licensor does not foreclose itself from making additional licenses involving the same subject matter and same general scope. A nonexclusive license has been described as nothing more than a promise not to sue. It does not convey property rights in the information to the licensee.
42. "Notice." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(25) (1998 Official Text). Notice exists when a person has knowledge or has received notification or has reason to know of a fact. When or if notice may cease to be effective is not governed by this Act, but by other law.
43. "Notify" or "give notice." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(26) (1998 Official Text). This term is used when the essential event is the dispatch of notice, not its receipt. If receipt is the relevant standard, that is stated in the statute.
44. "Party." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(29) (1998 Official Text). Reference to a "party" includes a person acting through an agent.
45. "Person." This term refers to individuals (human beings) and to business or other organizations, whether or not treated in law as formal entities. It is distinguished from the narrower term, "individual," which refers only to a natural human being, whether acting as a representative or on the individual's own behalf.
46. "Published informational content." This is the type of information most closely associated with free expression. In previous technology, this type of information refers to newspapers, books, phonorecords and the like (which are outside the scope of this Act). To be within this definition, the information must be informational content, that is, intended to communicate to a human being. Informational content is published content when created for or distributed to a group of recipients as a whole in generally the same form. The term includes interactive content and content made publicly available in a database, even if only portions of it are used by individual recipients who, for example, may search the database using a computer program. The information is still generally available; the end user selects from available information. That is like the reader of a newspaper who reads part, but not all, of the newspaper. The term also includes the informational product of automated systems that supply selected portions of a larger database to individual licensees based on programmed parameters.
Published informational content does not include content tailored by individuals (human beings) acting on behalf of the licensor to meet a specific recipient's needs, nor does it apply to information provided in a special relationship of reliance. The phrase "special relationship of reliance" refers to transactions in which the provider knows that a particular licensee plans to rely on particular data provided by the licensor and that the licensee expects the licensor to tailor the information to the client's specific business or personal needs. That type of relationship arises only with respect to licensors who possess unique or specialized expertise or who are in a special position of confidence and trust with the particular licensee such that reliance is justified and the licensor has a duty to act with care. In a special relationship of reliance the information provider is specifically aware of and personally tailors information to the needs of the particular licensee as an integral part of the provider's primary business. A reliance relationship does not arise for information made generally available to a group in standard form, even if those who receive the information subscribe to the service because they believe it is relevant to their commercial or personal needs.
47. "Receive." This definition distinguishes between performances and notices. As to performances, it corresponds to Uniform Commercial Code § 2-103(1)(e) (1998 Official Text). With respect to notices, a notice is received when a message is delivered to a place designated or held out by the recipient for such notices even if the place is controlled by a third party. Arrival at an appropriate private post office box is receipt even if the addressee does not remove or read the message until later. Similarly, arrival at an appropriate electronic mail address is receipt by the addressee. The definition is met by arrival at a location only if the person holds out that location or system as a place for receiving notices of the kind. Parties often require that notice be to a particular address or person. If parties agree to send notice to a particular e-mail address, arrival at that location suffices; delivery to a different e-mail address does not.
The message must be capable of being processed by an ordinary system of the type involved. This refers to the type of system in its general, reasonably expected configuration and not to an atypical configuration known or knowable only to the party operating the system. Whether the message actually is processed is not relevant to receipt; similarly, a letter placed in a party's post office box is received even if not opened.
48. "Record." A record must be in, or capable of being retrieved in, perceivable form. Electronic text recorded in a computer memory that could be printed or displayed from that memory constitutes a record. Similarly, a tape recording of an oral conversation or a video taping of actions could be a record.
49. "Release." A release is a waiver or a nonexclusive permission not accompanied by other commercial attributes such as an ongoing obligation to pay or an obligation to provide the means to make use of the information. A release is a form of license. The term is used in this Act to identify transactions in which the sole purpose is to permit use and applies where agreements of the type are often made on a less formal basis than a commercial license. Some releases are enforceable as "quasi-contracts." This Act does not change that law.
50. "Return." In this Act, a "return" refers to acts that restore a party to its initial position if the party rejected contract terms in a record and, as a result, the transaction will not be carried forward. See Sections 112, 208, and 209. A return requires redelivery to the licensor or its agent of any computer information already delivered that would have been covered by the rejected contract. When a licensee declines the contract, "return" entails reimbursement of any fees paid on re-delivery of all copies of the information and documentation. The information and documentation must be redelivered in their original condition. By consent of the licensor, the copies can be destroyed in accordance with its instructions. A right to a return under this Act applies only to computer information and does not affect goods, such as a computer that contains the software.
Return is not a remedy for breach. It is a right created by this Act or the agreement that arises if a party refuses contract terms but had previously committed to, or actually paid the contract fee. A right of return allows the party a meaningful opportunity to decide to accept or reject the contract. If a party accepts contract terms, there is no right to a return, but if the computer information is defective, the aggrieved party may have a right to refuse the product and recover the contract fee and any other appropriate damages as a remedy for breach.
A return must be sought within a reasonable time. What is a reasonable time depends on the terms of the agreement or, if the agreement is silent, the commercial context. Section 114.
A right to a return may arise in "bundled" information products (products that include separate information products transferred as a whole for a single fee). Pricing in bundled transactions is not based on summing the fees that would be required for each product in an unbundled setting; often, bundled products include information products provided for no or a lesser charge, even though the information might have a different price in other transactions. In some cases, there is no fee attributable to any of the bundled information products included with other products, such as a computer.
If separate bundled products are separately priced, a return is for the contract fee for the information product as to which the contract terms were rejected. Otherwise, a return must be of the entire bundled product and reimbursement of the entire price, if any, attributed to that entire product. For a return for a separately stated price to occur, the contract price for the item must be separately stated in the sense that the agreement identified an amount for the particular information. A court cannot unbundle products and estimate appropriate prices in what is often a complex commercial arrangement premised on the economics of bundling multiple products. If no price is attributed in the agreement to the bundled information products, a return does not require reimbursement of a fee since none has been charged.
51. "Scope." This definition refers to contract terms that define the central elements of a license that relate to aspects of use of the information. Scope terms define the product. The same computer information has entirely different commercial characteristics and value depending on the scope of rights licensed. A license that allows use of a word processing program in a single computer is not the same product as a license to make and distribute copies of that word processing software throughout a region. Neither license is the same product as a license that transfers a copy but limits use to three days at home. They are all different even though the program and the copy may be exactly the same and the differences can only be determined by reading the license.
52. "Send." This definition adapts Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(38)(1998 Official Text) to cover electronic notices. In modern technology sending a message does not require that the information move from one location to another. Electronic transfers often involve processes that copy the information into another location or that make it available in a system shared with or accessible by the recipient. The message must be capable of being processed by the type of system involved. This refers to the type of system in its general, reasonably expected configuration and not to atypical system configurations. Of course, if the sender has knowledge of the details of the actual system to which it is sending the message, its actions may need to take that knowledge into account. The phrase "in addition" makes it clear that the electronic sending must also comply with relevant criteria for other media, such as use of a commercially reasonable carrier. The message or item sent must be directed to a location or system that is held out as a place for receiving communications of that kind.
53. "Standard form." The definition refers to forms, not standard terms. A form consists of record containing a group of terms prepared for frequent use as a contract. The definition does not cover a tailored contract comprised of "terms" selected from multiple prior agreements. The form must have been actually used without negotiation other than of the terms noted in the definition. If a standard form is offered but then negotiated or changed other than with respect to those ordinarily tailored terms, the resulting record of the contract is not a standard form. "Negotiated" for purposes of this definition means actually bargained for or about, or pointed out with an opportunity for meaningful bargaining, even if assented to without actual bargaining.
54. "Term." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-201(42) (1998 Official Text). The word refers to a discernible element of an agreement. The word "clause" has the same meaning.
55. "Termination." This definition is from Uniform Commercial Code § 2-106 (1998 Official Text). The effect of terminating a contract is discussed in Sections 616-618.
56. "Transfer." This word, as used with respect to conveyances of contractual interests, refers to actual transfers of a contractual interest, as contrasted to agreements that merely employ another person to act on behalf of the transferor under a delegation or sublicense. Some of these transfers might be described as an assignment of the contract.
57. "Usage of trade." This term is from Uniform Commercial Code § 1-205 (1998 Official Text). This Act treats usage of trade as a factor in determining the commercial meaning of the agreement. The language of an agreement is interpreted as meaning what it may fairly be expected to mean to parties involved in the particular commercial transaction in a given locality or in a given vocation or trade. A usage of trade must have the "regularity of observance" indicated in the text. It is not required that a usage be "ancient or immemorial," "universal" or the like. Full recognition is available for new uses and for uses currently observed by the majority of merchants, even though some do not. There is room also for appropriate recognition of usage agreed by merchants in trade codes.
58. Subsection b refers to various provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code that define additional terms used in this Act. Unless otherwise expressly indicated, the reference is to the Official Text as of 1998.
SECTION 103. SCOPE; EXCLUSIONS.
(a) This [Act] applies to computer information transactions.
(b) Except for subject matter excluded in subsection (d) and as otherwise provided in Section 104, if a computer information transaction includes subject matter other than computer information or subject matter excluded under subsection (d), the following rules apply:
(1) If a transaction includes computer information and goods, this [Act] applies to the part of the transaction involving computer information, informational rights in it, and creation or modification of it. However, if a copy of a computer program is contained in and sold or leased as part of goods, this [Act] applies to the copy and the computer program only if:
(A) the goods are a computer or computer peripheral; or
(B) giving the buyer or lessee of the goods access to or use of the program is ordinarily a material purpose of transactions in goods of the type sold or leased.
(2) Subject to subsection (d)(3)(A), if a transaction includes an agreement for creating, or for obtaining rights to create, computer information and a motion picture, this [Act] does not apply to the agreement if the dominant character of the agreement is to create or obtain rights to create a motion picture. In all other such agreements, this [Act] does not apply to the part of the agreement that involves a motion picture excluded under subsection (d)(3), but does apply to the computer information.
(3) In all other cases, this [Act] applies to the entire transaction if the computer information and informational rights, or access to them, is the primary subject matter, but otherwise applies only to the part of the transaction involving computer information, informational rights in it, and creation or modification of it.
(c) To the extent of a conflict between this [Act] and [Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code], [Article 9] governs.
(d) This [Act] does not apply to:
(1) a financial services transaction;
(2) an insurance services transaction;
(3) an agreement to create, perform or perform in, include information in, acquire, use, distribute, modify, reproduce, have access to, adapt, make available, transmit, license, or display:
(A) a motion picture or audio or visual programming, other than in (i) a mass-market transaction or (ii) a submission of an idea or information or release of informational rights that may result in making a motion picture or similar information product; or
(B) a sound recording, musical work, or phonorecord as defined or used in Title 17 of the United States Code as of July 1, 1999, or an enhanced sound recording, other than in the submission of an idea or information or release of informational rights that may result in the creation of such material or a similar information product.
(4) a compulsory license;
(5) a contract of employment of an individual, other than an individual hired as an independent contractor to create or modify computer information, unless the independent contractor is a freelancer in the news reporting industry as that term is commonly understood in that industry;
(6) a contract that does not require that information be furnished as computer information or a contract in which, under the agreement, the form of the information as computer information is otherwise insignificant with respect to the primary subject matter of the part of the transaction pertaining to the information;
(7) unless otherwise agreed between the parties in a record:
(A) telecommunications products or services provided pursuant to federal or state tariffs; or
(B) telecommunications products or services provided pursuant to agreements required or permitted to be filed by the service provider with a federal or state authority regulating those services or under pricing subject to approval by a federal or state regulatory authority; or
(8) subject matter within the scope of [Article 3, 4, 4A, 5, [6,] 7, or 8 of the Uniform Commercial Code].
(e) As used in subsection (d)(3)(B), "enhanced sound recording" means a separately identifiable product or service the dominant character of which consists of recorded sounds, but which includes (i) statements or instructions whose purpose is to allow or control the perception, reproduction, or communication of those sounds or (ii) other information, as long as recorded sounds constitute the dominant character of the product or service.
(f) In this section:
(1) "Audio or visual programming" means audio or visual programming that is provided by broadcast, satellite, or cable, as defined or used in the Communications Act of 1934 and related regulations as they existed on July 1, 1999, or by similar methods of delivery.
(2) "Motion picture" means:
(A) "motion picture" as defined in Title 17 of the United States Code as of July 1, 1999; or
(B) a separately identifiable product or service the dominant character of which consists of a linear motion picture, but which includes (i) statements or instructions whose purpose is to allow or control the perception, reproduction, or communication of the motion picture or (ii) other information, as long as the motion picture constitutes the dominant character of the product or service.
Definitional Cross References: Section 102: "Agreement"; "Consumer"; "Computer"; "Computer information"; "Computer information transaction"; "Consumer"; "Copy"; "Electronic"; "Financial services transaction"; "Good faith"; "Goods"; "Information"; "Insurance services transaction"; "License"; "Mass-market transaction"; "Party".
1. General Structure. This section states the scope of this Act. Subsection (a) states the affirmative scope. Subsections (b) and (c) establish rules for transactions where more than one subject matter is involved and not all of the subject matter is within subsection (a). Subsection (d) sets out exclusions from the Act.
2. Transactions in Computer Information. This Act deals with contracts and not property law. It applies to computer information transactions. In a computer information transaction, the transferee seeks the information and contractual rights to use it. Unlike a buyer of goods, a purchaser (e.g., buyer, lessee, or licensee) of computer information has little interest in the diskette or tape that originally contained the information after that information has been loaded into a computer, unless the information remains on that media and nowhere else. Indeed, in online transactions in computer information, there is often no tangible medium at all.
The scope of this Act turns initially on the definition of "computer information transaction." Section 102(11). "Computer information transactions" are agreements that deal with the creation, modification, access to, license, or distribution of computer information. Section 102(a)(11). "Computer information" is information in a form directly capable of being processed by, or obtained from, a computer and any copy, associated documentation, or packaging. Section 102(a)(10). As stated in subsections (b) and (c), if a transaction is a computer information transaction but also involves other subject matter, this Act ordinarily applies only to the aspects of the transaction that involve "computer information."
This Act deals with a variety of transactions central to the information economy where the contractual subject matter is computer information. However, the mere fact that communications about a transaction, such as an application for a loan or employment, are sent or recorded in digital form does not place the transaction within this Act. Thus, a contract for airplane transportation is not a computer information transaction even though the ticket is in digital form. The subject matter is not computer information, but the service - transportation. A contract to create and publish a print book does not become a computer information transaction simply because the author chooses or is required to deliver the work on a computer diskette. Similarly, an insurance policy prepared in digital form is not a computer information transaction; it is a contract for insurance coverage the terms of which are evidenced in digital form. A contract for a digi